Institution for Social and Policy Studies

Advancing Research • Shaping Policy • Developing Leaders

Cognitive Biases and the Strength of Political Arguments

ISPS Data Archive: Terms of Use

By using, contributing, and/or downloading files associated with scholarly studies available on the ISPS Data Archive, you agree to these terms and conditions.

Please read the ISPS Data Archive Terms of Use.

Author(s): 

Kevin Arceneaux

ISPS ID: 
D079
Research design: 
Data type: 
Survey
Data source(s): 

Author.

Field date: 
May 1, 2006
Location: 
Location details: 
Study 1: United States - PA, Study 2: International
Unit of observation: 
Individuals
Sample size: 
Study 1: 210, Study 2: 300
Inclusion/exclusion: 
Study 1: Most of the subjects were students at Temple University, but a handful (n=10) was drawn fromthe broader community. Study 2: Amazon.com Mechanical Turk panel
Randomization procedure: 
Random Assignment
Treatment: 
Study 1: Reading mock newspapers articles. Bias-congruent condition read a one-sided argument in support of the risky choice framed negatively, counterargument condition read a one-sided argument in support of the risk-averse choice, and it was framedmore positively, competing arguments condition were presented with both arguments and saw both frames. (+control group) Study 2: A two-sided argument about a political controversy surrounding a proposal to ban high school students from forming gay-straight alliance clubs, where they confronted both a pro and anti argument that was framed either in terms of losses or gains. Emotion was manipulated by asking subjects to view a series of pictures under the pretext that they were to “provide a descriptive tag for each image,” which is a common task in the Mechanical Turk environment.
Treatment administration: 
Study 1: Mock newspaper article, Study 2: Text argument and image
Outcome measures: 
Study 1: Attitudes toward developing a new flu vaccine, Study 2: Support for banning gay-straight alliance clubs
Archive date: 
2012
Archive contributor: 
Limor Peer
Owner: 
Author
Owner contact: 

isps(at)yale(dot)edu

Terms of use: 

Academic, non-commercial; see ISPS Terms of Use /data/data/login/isps-data-archive/

Discipline: 
Area of study: 
Data file numbersort descending Description File format Size File url
D079F01 Dataset - Study 1 Stata (12.0) .dta 22528 Download file
D079F02 Dataset - Study 2 Stata (12.0) .dta 26624 Download file
D079F03 Dataset - Fig 2-3 Stata (12.0) .dta 1024 Download file
D079F04 Dataset - Fig 5-6 Stata (12.0) .dta 2048 Download file
D079F05 Dataset - Study 1 Excel .csv 21504 Download file
D079F06 Dataset - Study 2 Excel .csv 28672 Download file
D079F07 Dataset - Fig 2-3 Excel .csv 6144 Download file
D079F08 Dataset - Fig 5-6 Excel .csv 6144 Download file
D079F09 Codebook - Study 1 DDI-XML 22528 Download file
D079F10 Codebook - Study 2 DDI-XML 26624 Download file
D079F11 Codebook - Fig 2-3 DDI-XML 10240 Download file
D079F12 Codebook - Fig 5-6 DDI-XML 11264 Download file
D079F13 Program file - Tables Stata (12.0) .do 2048 Download file
D079F14 Program file - Figures Stata (12.0) .do 1024 Download file
D079F15 Program file - Tables R 6144 Download file
D079F16 Program file - Figures R 3072 Download file
D079F17 Output file .txt 30720 Download file
D079F18 Metadata record Adobe acrobat (8.0) .pdf 199680 Download file